Apple and Google accused of helping 'enforce gender apartheid' by hosting Saudi government app that tracks women and stops them leaving the country
Apple and Google accused of helping 'enforce gender
apartheid' by hosting Saudi government app that tracks women and stops them
leaving the country
By Bill Bostock February 9, 2019
Apple and Google have been criticized by rights groups
for hosting Absher, an app which allows men in Saudi Arabia to track and
control where women travel.
Absher is a Saudi government website, which INSIDER
reported on at length last week. It is available on Google Play and iTunes, and
has been downloaded more than one million times.
Under Saudi law, every woman has a legal
"guardian" who can restrict her travel to specific airports and
routes, and get automated alerts when they cross borders.
Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and a women's
rights activist told INSIDER that Apple and Google should reconsider hosting
the app.
Yasmine Mohammed, a critic of Saudi Arabia, said:
"There's a definite tragedy in the world's most technologically
progressive platforms, Apple and Google, facilitating the most archaic
misogyny."
Neither Apple nor Google responded to repeated requests
for comment.
Read INSIDER's full report on Absher here.
Apple and Google have been accused of helping to
"enforce gender apartheid" in Saudi Arabia, by offering a sinister
app which allows men to track women and stop them leaving the country.
Both Google Play and iTunes host Absher, a government web
service which allows men to specify when and how women can cross Saudi borders,
and to get close to real-time SMS updates when they travel.
Absher also has benign functions — like paying parking
fines — but its travel features have been identified by activists and refugees
as a major factor in the continued difficulty women have leaving Saudi Arabia.
Neither Apple nor Google responded to repeated requests
for comment from INSIDER over several days prior to publication.
INSIDER reported on the existence of Absher last week,
along with the story of Shahad al-Mohaimeed, a Saudi teen refugee who evaded
the system to claim asylum in Sweden.
This is a screenshot from a desktop version of Absher,
labelled with added labels to explain its functions:
Since the story was published, Human Rights Watch and
Amnesty International have both expressed concern about Google and Apple's role
in hosting the app, which has been installed on smartphones more than 1 million
times.
Human Rights Watch told INSIDER: "Apple and Google
have rules against apps that facilitate threats and harassment.
"Apps like this one can facilitate human rights
abuses, including discrimination against women."
Amnesty International told INSIDER that the SMS alerts
are "another example of how the Saudi Arabian government has produced
tools to limit women's freedoms."
It called on Apple and Google to accept that the app is
being used to harm women, and demand changes to stop it happening in future.
Yasmine Mohammed, an ex-Muslim and outspoken critic of
Saudi Arabia, told INSIDER that the companies are "facilitating the most
archaic misogyny" and help the Saudi government to enforce "gender
apartheid."
According to the Google Play store, Absher has been
downloaded on Android devices more than 1 million times. Apple does not
disclose download figures for apps.
The alert system, which can be set up insider Absher, is
one of the main reasons women trying to flee Saudi Arabia get caught, according
to activists.
The function tips off male guardians while the fleeing
women can still be apprehended, according to Dr. Taleb al-Abdulmohsen, a Saudi
refugee who sought asylum in Germany.
Adam Coogle, a Middle East researcher at Human Rights
Watch, also told INSIDER about the SMS alerts and corroborated al-Abdulmohsen's
story.
Here are the criticisms of Google and Apple in full:
Rothna Begum, Middle East researcher for Human Rights
Watch:
"Apple and Google have rules against apps that
facilitate threats and harassment. Apps like this one can facilitate human
rights abuses, including discrimination against women."
"In evaluating whether an app should be allowed, app
store providers should be considering the broader context of the purpose of the
app, how it is used in practice, and whether it facilitates serious abuses.
Companies should apply extra scrutiny to government-operated apps in
particular."
"Even though the app is more general purpose, the
government could simply remove the guardianship tracking functionality from the
app, and continue to offer the rest of the functionality. (In other words, we
wouldn't say that governments shouldn't be able to offer government services
through mobile apps, just not services that facilitate abuses.)"
Dana Ahmed, Saudi Arabia researcher for Amnesty
International:
"We call on these companies to assess the risk of
human rights abuses and mitigate harm that these apps may have on women."
"This is another example of how the Saudi Arabian
government has produced tools to limit women's freedoms."
"The tracking of women in this way curtails their
movement and once again highlights the disturbing system of discrimination
under the guardianship laws."
Yasmine Mohammed, ex-Muslim activist who campaigns and
writes on women's rights:
"There's a definite tragedy in the world's most
technologically progressive platforms, Apple and Google, facilitating the most
archaic misogyny.
"What irony. In the West these technologies are used
to improve lives and in Saudi Arabia they're used to enforce gender
apartheid."
Comments
Post a Comment