France Targets Apple, Google for ‘Abusive Commercial Practices’
France Targets Apple, Google for ‘Abusive Commercial
Practices’
Move comes after investigation into how the tech giants
treat French start-ups that develop and sell applications for mobile phones
The French Finance Ministry said it has filed a complaint
asking a Paris court to order Apple and Google to end “abusive commercial
practices.”
By Sam Schechner Updated March 14, 2018 10:15 a.m. ET
PARIS—France wants to fine Apple Inc. AAPL -1.05% and
Google for allegedly taking advantage of smaller French software developers,
targeting two of the U.S.’s biggest companies, as tensions heat up between the
two continents after President Donald Trump said he would adopt new tariffs
that could hit European firms.
The French Finance Ministry said Wednesday it has filed a
complaint asking a Paris court to order Apple and Google, a unit of Alphabet
Inc., to end “abusive commercial practices” following a three-year government
investigation into how the Silicon Valley companies treat French start-ups that
develop and sell applications for mobile phones. Some developers and publishers
are unhappy that Apple and Google at times take a cut of in-app purchases and
get access to more data on their users and subscribers than the developers do.
“No matter how powerful Google and Apple may be, they
cannot treat our start-ups and developers the way they do today,” French
Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire said on French radio.
“We believe our terms comply with French laws and are
looking forward to making our case in court,” a Google spokeswoman said. Apple
didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment.
The French finance ministry says there’s no connection
between taking on tech firms and the U.S.’s new tariffs and taxes.
However, France has recently become more vocal about its
actions against U.S. firms. A finance ministry official said Europe “needs to
stand up and defend its own interests.”
President Trump has said he would implement new tariffs
on steel and aluminum imports, and the U.S. passed a tax overhaul that could
hit European tech and pharmaceutical firms operating in the U.S. Each side has
accused the other of protectionism, raising the specter of a trade war.
Mr. Le Maire plans to speak with Commerce Secretary
Wilbur Ross later Wednesday about the U.S. tariff plan and push for an
exemption of the EU, according to the finance ministry official.
Mr. Le Maire has been a prime agitator in other efforts
to rein in the tech giants. The EU is considering levying a new tax on the
revenue—instead of the profit—of tech giants. Mr. Le Maire and others argue
that tech giants use legal loopholes to shift too much profit to tax havens,
and that until laws can be changed to stamp out such practices, Europe must tax
revenue instead.
Mr. Le Maire said Wednesday he is pushing the EU to adopt
the new tax this year. But it remains unclear whether the proposal can muster
the unanimous support from EU countries that it needs to become law. Ireland,
Luxembourg and other low-tax EU countries where many tech firms are
headquartered have expressed opposition to the measure.
The case France announced Wednesday seeks to address a
“significant imbalance” in the way Google and Apple treat developers, the
finance ministry said, adding the government is seeking to fine each company
two million euros.
“When our developers want to sell their app on Google or
Apple, the fees are imposed on them,” Mr. Le Maire said. “That’s unacceptable.
It’s not the economy we want.”
https://www.wsj.com/articles/france-targets-apple-google-for-abusive-commercial-practices-1521031428
Comments
Post a Comment